A major point of Board Game Arena is getting to try games without going out and buying them. (_The_ major point is to play games with people who aren’t in the same room as you) Sometimes, you find an actual gem. And sometimes you find a train wreck.
The Great American Fox Hunt turned out to be a train wreck.
It is themed around an international hunting competition. I got curious if it was named for a real event I just had never heard of. And apparently… it’s a nickname for a motocross event at Firebird Raceway in Idaho. (Not to be confused with a nigh identically named track in Arizona) So, no, it’s apparently not named for a real event.
You’ve got a 96-card deck of prey animals. Each player gets a five-card deck of hunters, which are really bid cards. And there’s a deck of hound cards you can buy to add to your hunter deck throughout the game. And they all have numbers on them.
The Great American Fox Hunt is basically a variant on blind bidding. On your turn, you lay down one or more hunter cards. Then you flip a prey card. If your total is equal or more than the prey number, you get it.
If you don’t equal or beat the prey number, you are tracking the animal and the cards stay in front of you. Another player, on their turn, can poach the animal rather than hunting an unknown. They can add hunter cards to your hunter cards to claim the animal. Yes, they get to use your cards to win a card.
You win by collecting a set number of one given animal. You have to get six squirrels compared three bears but there are thirty squirrels compared to thirteen bears.
My biggest beef with the game is the degree that there is how much luck determines the game. Bidding a lot so you are very likely to get a card feels like the best choice but that also burns resources for potentially little reward.
And poaching, the one time you can bid with precision for a sure thing, feels surprisingly mean spirited. Not only is there no way to defend against it, your opponent is literally using your bad luck against you. I love me some direct confrontation in games but this just feels like kicking someone when they are down.
The blind bidding against the game itself, mechanic brought back memories of a handheld solitaire game called Foothold Enterprises. But that game had a much more narrow range of odds, no mechanic like the poaching, and ways to earn special powers. The Great American Fox Hunt doesn’t have any of the elements that made me like Foothold Enterprises.
What it really brought back memories of the times I would buy some random game at a convention, have it hit the table, and be really disappointed. I am glad that PGA let me have that experience without wasting money or storage space.