Showing posts with label Phonogram. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Phonogram. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 9, 2025

The Singles Club uses pop culture to make high art

I had read that Phonogram vol 2 The Singles Club was the right place to actually start the series, the best of the three volumes. 

Well, I read the first volume first anyway. And quite enjoyed it. I found the complaints that you have to be familiar with the indie music scene for it to make any sense to be heavily exaggerated. You just have to understand fandom in general. 

Then I picked up The Singles Club. And couldn’t put it down lol

Spoilers

Spoilers

Spoilers

Spoilers

Spoilers

Spoilers

Spoilers

Spoilers

The Singles Club describes the same night at a club seven different times. Wikipedia claims it’s based on a real event but I couldn’t find any other reference to that. More than that, there isn’t any dramatic moment in this evening. It’s eight different people having a night out.

I also want to note that this isn’t a Rashomon story, at least as I understand the term. None of the stories contradict each other. They are just different points of view.

(Rashomon is a movie that has really stuck with me. I know Kurosawa didn’t invent the concept but, man, he created such a definitive example. The dead husband testifying through a medium was so wild to me. And I also appreciate that every single person, even the woodcutter, turns out to be lying)

But that formula wouldn’t be enough to make for a good read. No, the reason the Singles Club is good is because the art and the writing come together to give memorable, believable, flawed, sympathetic characters. 

And the characters are everything. All of the action is internal. There isn’t a dramatic plot structure. Instead, we watch pretty much every character end a touch wiser than they started. 

And then they stick the landing with Kid-With-Knife. Who isn’t a serial killer and whose name I _think_ is a reference to the band Knife. A band I have only heard of through Phonogram. He’s a big, loveable goof. He was the Chas Chandler to David’s John Constantine in the first volume. And he’s convinced David to teach him about Phonomancy.

And KWK works so well as an endnote because he is such a contrast to every other character. He may be a loveable idiot but he knows who he is and he is comfortable in his own skin. His reaction to phonomancy instructions being listen to the music until it fills you is ‘Hell, everybody does that’

Truth to tell, as an old duffer, I related to Rue Britannia better. However, as a work of art, the Singles Club is better. The journey seems to go nowhere but takes you so far.

Wednesday, June 25, 2025

You don’t have know indie music to appreciate Phonogram

Until earlier this week as of my writing this, I had never heard of the comic book Phonogram until I saw a clickbait article saying it was one of the all time greats of comic book-dom. So I found a copy of the first volume and read it.

Summary: It isn’t some forgotten V for Vendetta but it is a solid, even thoughtful read. In fact, Phonogram is one more (of oh so many) arguments that comic books are literature, not mindless gloop.

Spoilers

Spoilers

Spoilers 

Spoilers

Spoilers 

Spoilers

Spoilers

Spoilers

In the world of Phonogram, phonomancers are magic users who use music to reinforce or change their identities, how people see them, things like that. In other words, pretty much what people do in the real world. And, indeed, it is set in the ‘real’ world and real music is so imbedded in it that there are extensive annotations for someone like me who just likes to listen to music and not be an authority on it.

The first volume, Rue Britannia, is about phonomancer David Kohl looking into a group of retro fans trying to resurrect the patron goddess of Brittpop. And, if you are like me, you’ll need to look up that it was a mid-90s indie movement and that you do know some of the bands.

The actual underlining plot, while it involves undead goddesses and cultists, is David realizing what a shallow, pretentious little git he is. And, by the end, he is still a pretentious jerk but he’s gained some awareness and empathy.

And Phonogram also has something to say about music. Or, really, our relationship to music. That a song can be shallow or objectively terrible but still meaningful to us. And that’s okay. That the music we listened to when we were nineteen will always be the best music. (Don’t actually agree with that but I understand the idea)

Hellblazer was clearly a major influence on at least the first volume of Phanogram. David Kohl and the Garth Ennis-flavor of John Constantine have a lot in common. Some of David’s lines I would have been right at home in one of Ennis’s scripts. But since it is a self-contained story, David is allowed to actually grow.

After reading Rue Britannia, the second volume, The Singles Club, considered to be the best of the three volumes, is on my shortlist to read.