Monday, November 16, 2026

Honestly, history is bigger than six glasses

 A History of the World in Six Glasses by Tom Standage describes how beer, wine, spirits, coffee, tea and Coca Cola drove cultural development. I enjoyed the book but with a number of caveats. 


The biggest one being that this book does not cover the history of the world. The section on coffee does touch on the Arab world and China gets some mention in tea but the driving focus is western culture. 


I also found myself questioning, how much of a driving factor in the development of civilization were some of these beverages. How much is this chicken or the egg argument. To be fair, unlike some other histories of beverages I’ve read, Standage leaves that open to question as well.


Years and years ago, I read the novelization of the Doctor Who radio play Slipback by Eric Saward. My distant memory of the book was that it was terrible but one thing that stuck with me was an argument that all anthropological development was driven by alcohol. It included things like smithing was developed just to make corkscrews and borders were created just to justify duty free shops.


Many years later, I found out that this is actually a real theory. At least as far as primitive beer being the driving factor in the transition from hunting and gathering to agriculture. Standage comments on this theory but also says that it is too simplistic so he gets points from me there.


Ultimately, the book is not a comprehensive history of the world or western culture or even the individual beverages. Of course, in a book this short, none of those would have been a reasonable expectation.


While the book does give a broad overview of the history and arguments about the influence of each beverage, it was the occasional focused bits I found interesting. Standage includes mildly harsh histories of the East India Company and John Stith Pemberton. And I say mild because there is plenty of room to be a lot stronger.


I have gotten to the habit, if I am going to read a book about either history or science, checking the bibliography. If I can’t even find one, then I’m going to give the book a pass. If we are looking at truth, there has to be a certain standard. Six Glasses had just barely enough bibliography for me to pass muster.


I was very entertained by A History of the World in Six Glasses and glad to have read It. But I’m not sure I was educated.

No comments:

Post a Comment