Monday, September 12, 2016

Mint Works - minimalism at work

The Kickstarter for Mint Works is almost at an end and it's been funded well and above the goal. Enough that a number of stretch goals have been met. When a game is that small, even a little bit extra can be a big expansion.

I've kept my eye on Mint Works ever since I first saw it as part of a PnP contest. I've been interested in micro games pretty much since I got into board games but Mint Works manages to be something different from other micro games I've seen.

It does that just by being a worker placement game and a pretty straight foward one at that. The actions are pretty simple. Get more workers, get building plans, building buildings from plans. Whoever gets seven points in buildings first wins.

The original version of the game consisted of two pages of cards, plus whatever tokens you used for workers. I know the Kickstarter version will have more cards but we are still talking tiny. Smaller than any other worker placement game I've come across.

One difference from most worker placement games I've seen is that you don't get your workers back. They as effectively currency and you need to get more through a very limited income or actions or buildings. Still, since everyone is competing for a limited pool of actions so the basic mechanic of worker placement holds true.

The placeholder for simplest worker placement game for me used to be Sticky Fingers. That's a game where you play rival thieves and you have to gather up tools, use those tools to steal stuff and then fence the stuff off for money which is called points in the game.

And I do like Sticky Fingers. While it is simple, it has enough tension and complexity to keep it interesting. However, what it is not is an engine builder. The board is effectively the engine and you are fighting to use it the most efficiently. 

Mint Works is in the running to be my new simplest worker placement game. It is honestly simpler and it is a worker placement game. And, as a micro game, it feels a different role as far as gaming needs are concerned.

And, unlike Sticky Fingers, Mint Works is an engine builder. The powers of the buildings give you are awfully simple but they are there. You definitely have to build up your infrastructure as well as going for points.,What I am uncertain of is how strong it's replay value is. The Kickstarter version, with more cards, does add promise for replay.

Mint Works is definitely a fascinating work of minimalism.

https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/200077/mint-works

Why For Sale is a classic

For Sale is one of those games that is a definitive classic. It came out in 1997 and it's given the world almost twenty years of solid gaming since then.

For Sale is a game about the gentle art of flipping houses. In the first half of the game, you are buying houses, preferably as cheap as possible. In the second half, you sell those houses, preferably for a lot.

The game consists of two decks of cards, houses and checks, and a stack of coins. The houses have a numeric value from one to thirty while the checks range from zero to fifteen. My copy, at least, has pretty goofy houses, ranging from a cardboard box to a space station. I'm willing to bet there are editions where the coins are cards too. 

Everyone gets a starting pot of coins, which you'll use for bidding in the first phase. You deal out houses equal to the number of players and then the bidding starts. You go round and round the table, with folks either raising or passing. If you pass, you give the bank half your bid (which could be zero) and take the cheapest house that's left. Only the winner pays their full amount but they get the highest value house.

After you run out of houses, you start the second phase. Selling those houses. Deal out checks equal to the number of players. Everyone secretly chooses a house and simultaneously reveals them.  Checks then get handed out in order of house value. You know, highest value gets the highest check. Remember, some of them as worth zero so you can get hosed.

After all the checks get auctioned off, you count up the value of your checks and whatever coins you have left from the first part. Whoever has the most money wins!

Obviously, For Sale is an auction game (and by Dora's, not Knizia! That always surprised me) but it's a gentle one. Every round, everyone gets a card, no matter what. And, if you're lucky and/or patient, even that lousy cardboard box might be worth something.

At the same time, the game rewards good judgement. You have to know when to pass, when to unload your junk houses and when to pull out your high value homes. No one gets buried but good play wins the day.

It's that combination of simple, easy to understand rules with forgiving auctions and meaningful decisions that has made For Sale a classic. 

I have heard For Sale called the king of fillers, meaning it's a game that takes less than a half hour and can be used to fill in the time around longer games. The word filler often gets a lot of flack, although less since Love Letter inspired waves of micro games. Personally, life with a toddler makes games like that a real gift. And For Sale takes the fifteen minutes it takes to play and makes them a real fun gaming experience. 

I haven't played For Sale as much as I have wanted to. It came into my collection when I was trying out new games constantly and it got lost in the shuffle. Despite that, I remember how it was always fun with every group I played it with. A lot of the games I played from that period in my gaming life have left my collection but For Sale is a game I'm going to hang onto.

https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/172/sale

Friday, September 9, 2016

Modern Art and the art of auctions

Modern Art is not my favorite auction game. That's probably Ra, as far as games where the primary mechanic is having auctions. For Sale and High Society are also high up there. (In fact, I'd even go so far as to say if you only own one auction game, For Sale is one of your best choices)

But Modern Art wasn't just my introduction to auction games. It was a great introduction because it is a crash course on auctions. It is one of the fundamental games on the subject.

Instead of going over the rules in detail, I'll put in a link to the review I wrote back in 2005: https://boardgamegeek.com/thread/88939/essential-auction-game Okay, let me get back to talking about the game.

Modern Art pulls off being such a fundamental auction game by using four different methods of auction, not counting the double auction. You got the traditional caller auction, the blind auction, the once around auction and the set price auction.

Really, the only auction it doesn't cover per se is the moat common form of auction in games, going around until everyone but one player has dropped out. 

Modern Art also has a really neat economic system going on, with only the three artists earning any money at the end of each season but the values adding up through out the game. Some folks have argued that that keeps it from being a 'pure' auction game. Considering that Knizia basically sawed the auctions off in order to create Modern Art the Card Game, I can see that.

Still, the auctions and the determination of the value of each system are all tightly knit together to form the economy of the game. In particular, the players are auctioning off the paintings to each other and pocketing the profits themselves. Everyone is invested in the economy of the game.

I'll admit that one of reasons Modern Art isn't at the top of my auction list is because people who overbid can not only knock themselves out of the game but literally hand the game over to someone else. Fortunately, you can teach people what the maximum potential value of a painting is but not everyone is good at listening :P

Modern Art is a very engaging game, involving all the players. It really explores auctions and has a tight economy tying everything together.  It's a really fun game that is great for exploring game mechanics. It really has earned a place in my collection. 

http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/118/modern-art

Shopkins and matching games, gotta catch them all!

I am coming to the conclusion that matching games are even more common then roll-and-move games when it comes to board games that are aimed at the under five set.

Not that I am really complaining, seeing as how matching games still offer some real choices, as opposed rolling a die and doing whatever it tells you. And I figure that learning matching skills and memory skills is at least as educational as learning how to count spaces.
 
But, wow, are there a lot of them out there. Every single licensed product under the sun has one, which makes sense. All you need is the artwork and you are ready to go. No further game development necessary.

So every time I find a matching game that has some kind of twist build into it, it's kind of interesting for me.

We recently picked up the Shopkins Make A Deal Matching game, based on the chibi Shopkins toys. Those are cute little anthropomorphized things you buy in stores. Seriously, it's that general. Food, jewelry, wheelbarrels, tennis rackets. If you can buy it with cold hard currency, they will make a cute little figurine of it.

The game follows the general matching game formula, building a grid of facedown tiles and flipping them over to find matches. You know the drill.

Where the twist comes in is that you get one point for each unique tile that you have. If you make a successful match, you can choose to take another turn or to make a deal.

If you make a deal, you get two choices. You can swap a tile with another player, netting you reach a point. Or you can flip a coin with heads letting you steal a tile from another player. It has to be one that they have two of, though. You don't get to steal points.

Mind you, that still not enough to make it really that interesting a game. The swap action only works if you have more than two players and with more than two players, it means that the people not involved in the swap are the ones actually taking a loss. More than that, the entire make a deal series of actions only works once people have got a collection of tiles.

For actual playing purposes, it still doesn't thrill me the way Spot It or Animal Upon Animal do. There are clearly more interesting games for toddlers out there. I still find it interesting to find an additional mechanic and one that fits the theme of got to catch them all.

Huh. Wonder if the mechanic was first developed for a Pokemon matching game.

Leadfoot Gettaway - an RPG for two players and one fast car

Leadfoot Gettaway is not just a two-page RPG, it's also a game straddles the line between a role playing game and an adventure board game. To be fair, that's a super thin line and I don't know of an adventure board game that doesn't have one foot in role playing. However, it's still a good trick for a game fits on a double-sided sheet of paper.

Part of the Indie Mixtape Megamix, Leadfoot Gettaway plays out a particularly tough job  in the life of a Driver. You know, the role that's pretty much defined the career of Jason Statham. Although, the genre has been around for a whole longer than that. Still, it lets you describe the game to someone in one sentence.

It's designed for two players. Obviously, someone gets to be the driver. They get to stat out the driver. Or, really, they get to stat out the car. The sweet ride gets four stats, ranging from one to four dice. The stat that stands out is Style, which adds gadgets to your car.
 
The other player is the passenger, which really means the game master. In addition to playing all of the NPC's, they use a regular deck of cards to randomly generate the road the driver is going on.

Without going into enough detail to tell you how to actually play the game without getting it, each card provide some sort of challenge to the driver. Red cards are cool stuff while black cards are tough challenges.

Something that amuses me is that while Leadfoot Gettaway is a ridiculously focused game, so focused that it could pass for a board game without much trouble, you can still really play with the setting. You could have it be set in the 70s with old school muscle cars or really hit the style and make it science fiction like Knight Rider or Speed Racer. Heck, you could make the sweet ride a horse and have it be a western.

Despite the simplicity and tight focus, there do feel like there are some meaningful gaps in the rule. For instance, other than losing gadgets or benefit tokens, there doesn't seem to be a damage system. In theory, eventually the driver will always make it.

Despite the super tight focus and some rules issues, I can immediately think of people I'd like to play Leadfoot Gettaway with. It didn't leave me in awe but the fact that I want to try it out says something.

Thursday, September 8, 2016

Auctions - a fun but dangerous mechanic

I had a recent discussion with a friend where discussed how we both liked auction games but we had both had experiences where poor player decisions had completely wrecked games.

I have seen games of Power Grid, where the power plants are auctioned off at the start of each turn, when a player has their heart set on a specific plant and effectively puts themselves out of the game. And auctions are only one part of that game.

More often than I care to remember, I've seen games of Modern Art get thrown out of whack when winning an auction becomes more important for someone than winning the game. That's particularly bad since you can figure out the maximum value of a painting and money from auctions usually goes into a player's pocket.

Although the worst game I've seen for bad player choices making everything fall apart is technically not an auction game, although I can see how it can be seen as one. That's the venerable Executive Decision by Sid Sackson. It's a game where supply and demand is entirely determined by the players and one player can wreck the whole economy. When played well, it's brilliant but when played poorly, it's a train wreck.

All of that said, there are ways that designers can help mitigate poorly bid auctions throwing games out whack. For instance, in For Sale, everyone will get a house or a check each round, no matter how poorly they've bid or how bankrupt they might be. Poor choices won't kick anyone out of the game.

The best game I've seen that manages to balance auctions is Ra. It does this primarily by only limiting the number of times you can win an auction and limiting how much you can bid. 

And, mind you, with players who understand what is going on and aren't going to be silly, auctions are a lot of fun. They create a metric ton of interaction and tension. And, if if you need to teach someone how to judge auctions, games like Ra and For Sale are great tools to do that, as well as just plain great games.

Wednesday, September 7, 2016

Employee of the Month - a profoundly quirky game

Employee of the Month is a game that has stuck in my head far longer than it has any right to. I got rid of my copy long ago since the game isn't that great to play but the quirky mechanics of the game continue to stick in my head.

Simply put, Employee of the Month is an auction game where everyone shares the same pool of money.

The way it works is every turn, a positive card and a negative card get auctioned off. Players take turns choosing from a row of money cards, high card winning.

And here's the twist. The money comes in two flavors, your reputation with other employees and with the boss. And you keep your winning money cards. At the end of the game, you only score the negative points if you have the most in either of those two denomination. (If you have the most in both, you get double the negative points)

Oh, just to make it even crazier, some of the points are special Kudos points. You only get those if you have the LOWEST in a denomination.

Employee of the Month uses a mechanic which I honestly haven't found anywhere else. It fits the theme of office politics surprisingly well and creates some interesting brinksmanship situations.

However, while it mechanically works, it has some playing issues. The two denominations are limited enough that it's easy for most anyone to do card counting. That makes it easy to force someone into a downward spiral to lose points from the negative cards. It's even easier to prevent someone from going for a Kudos strategy. Plus, there were times when a high negative point card would be tied to a low positive point card. Nobody would make a bid and that round would be a wash.

On top of those issues, there are other auctions games that are quick and portable. For Sale and High Society, for example, are stellar games that take up the same spot on the game shelf and are much, much better.

Employee of the Month is a strange, quirky game unlike anything I've seen. I'm glad to had a chance to try it back when I did. However, between the gameplay issues and the fact that there other light auction games I'd rather play, it didn't stay in my collection.