Showing posts with label manga. Show all posts
Showing posts with label manga. Show all posts

Monday, December 15, 2025

Excellent character work struggles against meh pacing in Shaman King

 Shaman King took me a while to get around to finishing. Frankly, if I hadn’t gotten the entire series in a bundle, I wouldn’t have. When it was a slog, it was a real slog. However, when it was good, it was really good and knowing that there was good stuff kept me picking it back up.


Spoilers


Spoilers


Spoilers 


Spoilers


Spoilers


Spoilers


Spoilers


Spoilers 


Shaman King is a manga from 1998 to 2004 that’s basically about a tournament of magic users to become the titular Shaman King, who is effectively omnipotent. What I recently learned some folks call a battle manga.


I apologize to fans of Shaman King but I found it to be a middle of the road, average Shonen manga. Which isn’t to say that it’s bad. In some respects, it’s quite good. However, it doesn’t sparkle.


The biggest problem, in my arrogant opinion, is the pacing. There are points where the story just drags. During the American road trip, I reached the point where I took a couple month break. And, while some of the flash backs felt both unnecessary and poorly timed. Horo Horo’s tragic backstory was revealed so close to the end of the story there was no room for character growth from it.


Honestly, a good edit would probably remove 20% of the entire series with significant improvement. Not that a weekly manga can get edited like that but hindsight is 20/20.


So what was good?


The actual character work is strong. More than that, the characters grow and change with well developed arcs. 


In particular, I enjoyed Yoh as a character. Which was a good thing because he’s the main character. Initially depicted as a slacker who wants power so he can be lazy, he is revealed to be a convincing and striking all-loving hero. 


Enemies becoming friends is a defining characteristic of the Shaman King. Yoh routinely invites people who just tried to kill him over for dinner. Near the end, Hai joins the heroes at some hot springs and Hai’s explicit goal as the big bad is to wipe out the human race.


While the lead up to the finale is a series of slog fights that I didn’t find nearly as compelling as the earlier tournament fights (and I got through knowing the end was near), the end being hugging it out with Hai worked well for me because the groundwork for that kind of ending had been well laid.


Ultimately, Shaman King’s positives do come out ahead of its issues for me but it just doesn’t have that je-ne-sais-quoi. (And it’s not the age. I find Hajime no Ippo, for instance, compelling (but socially dated as heck) and it’s ten years older)

Wednesday, May 28, 2025

I won’t spoil Fire Force but, trust me, it’s far weirder than it looks

Thanks to Bundle of Holding, I have read through the entirety of the Fire Force manga by Atsushi Ohkubi. My initial impression of it was My Hero Academia as fire fighters. Which isn’t remotely accurate but I love me some My Hero Academia so that was enough to get me on board.

Of course, in this case, the fire fighters in question almost all have pyrokinetic powers and fight fire monsters called infernals. In world that should be a whole lot more dystopian than it appears to be on the surface.

Around two hundred and fifty years earlier, there was a cataclysm that nearly destroyed the world. The Empire of Tokyo has risen up from the almost literal ashes. However, the world is haunted by spontaneous human combustion, which doesn’t bit turn people into dead ashes but infernals which are rampaging fiery beasts.

Fire Soldiers, most of whom have some kind of pyrokinetic powers, are a special division whose purpose is to put infernals down. A very important element of their job is that these are innocent people who they have to kill. Each squad even has clergy to administer last rites after or during the battle.

Killing infernals isn’t presented as a moral quandary per se. Eldritch fiery abominations killing people is an issue society has to address. However, it is presented as a moral burden. It has to be done but it is horrible.

Our hero is Shinra, a young fire soldier with the power to generate fire from his feet. This gives him the ability to fly, super speed, an unbelievable kick and a distaste for shoes. And I intentionally do mean our hero since being a hero is Shinra’s goal in life. 

Which would make him sound like a simple, naive character. However, he is a grounded by childhood tragedies that just get worse the more we learn about him. In fact, one of his greatest feats is being a functional, caring person after all he’s been through.

(As long as I’m talking about characters, I’ll address the elephant in the room, Tamaki, a fire soldier who is cursed to fall out of her clothes. It’s kept PG but seriously? To give Atsushi Ohkubo some credit, it is treated as a serious condition and something Tamaki has to struggle with socially and emotionally. On the other hand, her nemesis is a guy who passes out every time he sees her in her underwear and it’s treated as comedy. That’s trying to have your cake and eat it too. Yeah, it’s a problematic.)

Fire Force doesn’t have a monster-of-the-week formula. Instead, it is clearly big story arc pretty much from the beginning. And, without giving away any spoilers, boy do the plot twists keep hitting.

Now, I pretty much assume that all Shonen works are going to have major turning points where the status quo is not going to be coming back. If the words Jujutsu Kaisen and Shibuya Incident don’t make any sense to you, trust me, they are a darn good example of this. But Fire Force just keeps having them. 

The series keeps on having points where I told myself ‘ah, this is where everything changes’ And everything does change. But then we’d get another point where everything changes. Again, I want to avoid spoilers but near the end, I became convinced that if Atsushi Ohkubo and Grant Morrison ever met, it would destroy the universe.

I also want to note that many elements of Fire Force that I wrote off as only existing because of the rule of cool or silly fun end up having profound in-universe justifications. And from the aforementioned Jujutsu Kaisen to Jojo’s Bizarre Adventures, I’m used to in-universe explorations and explanations of weird powers. Fire Force still takes it to places most creators rarely go.

If I had only read one or two volumes, Fire Force wouldn’t have had much impact. But being able to read the whole series to the end made me appreciate what a crazy, mad fever dream it is.

Wednesday, October 9, 2024

The never ending Hajime no Ippo

 Hajime no Ippo really caught my eye just because it’s one of the longest running manga out there. It’s almost ten years older than One Piece and, like Luffy and company, it just keeps on going.


It’s a sports manga that about a teenage boxer named Ippo who unexpectedly turns out to have a real talent for boxing. One that requires a lot of training and hard work to come out but it’s there. We follow him on his journey of constantly finding new and challenging opponents.

And you may think that description tells you everything you need to know to know about Hajime no Ippo. And that’s pretty fair. It’s a thirty-five-year-old series. I’ve now read the first couple years worth and it feels like the blueprint for any given sports coming of age story.

Yes, Ippo goes into boxing absolutely clueless. Yes, he somehow has an innate talent for boxing. Yes, he keeps learning new techniques that are key for his next fight. And, yes, he pretty much never loses.

One of the reasons that Prince of Tennis is perhaps my favorite sports mangas is that Ryoma starts off being a great tennis player with years of training under his belt. (Another reason is because it is Dragonball Z as middle school tennis.) A key line for me is when Ryoma says that he loses every day and other players think is some kind deep thought. No, it’s because Ryoma has to play every day against his insane tennis god of a dad.

Two things that has drawn me in to Hajime no Ippo is that Ippo is a compellingly sweet, caring protagonist and that you get to read chapters of him training. The manga does its best to tell us that Ippo earns his victories and that he deserves them.

Another thing that has kept me reading is that the series is at least as much of a comedy as it is sports. Poor Ippo has it worse than Lucille Ball when it comes to being on the receiving end of slapstick.

I’ll also note that at least the early volumes feel dated in their overall social outlook. As an example, the reactions to Jason Ozuma, the first black boxer Ippo faces, don’t feel racist as much as they feel weird. To be fair, the manga subverts expectations by making Jason a sweetie like Ippo outside the ring.

Spoilers

Spoilers

Spoilers

Spoilers

Spoilers

Spoilers

Spoilers

Since I have read about Hajime no Ippo, I know that Ippo eventually retires due to fears of being punch drunk. Which is a kinder way of saying permanent neurological damage. And while punch drunk syndrome is a common boxing media trope, it’s also a real condition.

And I’m sure that, if Hajime no Ippo keeps on going, it will turn out he does not have punch drunk syndrome and make a triumphant return to the ring. But treating brain damage as a medical condition rather than an obstacle to overcome is a decision I respect.

I am positive that I am not going to read all of Hajime no Ippo. There is just too much content. However, even reading a little is fun.

Wednesday, September 11, 2024

I can’t do justice to Jujutsu Kaisen

 Over the last couple of years, I have been occasionally reading Jujutsu Kaisen. Frankly, it’s enough in demand at the library that I can’t binge it lol However, I do understand that it is currently one of the best selling manga in the world and I can see why.


After high school student Yuji accidentally eats the finger of a super evil and kind of dead sorcerer during a supernatural encounter. As you can well imagine, this gives him super powers. He is then thrust into the shadow war of cursed spirits and cursed spirit users.  To make things worse for him, the powers-rhat-be want to execute him because he could be possessed by the evil dude whose finger he are.

And… the powers-that-be are very justified in their fear.

According to people who know how to categorize manga better than I do, Jukutsu Kaisen is primarily a battle manga but it also has strong elements of urban fantasy and horror. Oh so much horror. Recoccuring antagonist Mahito is essentially body horror as a character. 

Every single cursed spirit and cursed spirit user has different and distinct abilities. It’s not quite as varied as My Hero Academia but it is light years past hitting each other harder. This nuance turns fights into chess matches. Kind of reminds me of stand battles from Jojo’s Bizarre Adventure and, yes, that’s a good thing.

And if that’s not a thing you like, the strong personalities of the characters (cursed spirit energy apparently comes from emotional damage so plenty of room for character) and the horror that sometimes require reading Attack on Titan for a breather are there too.

All and all, it’s buck wild. Over the top visuals, damaged but interesting characters and even the flashbacks have a fever pace. Jujutsu Kaisen just keeps delivering.

Wednesday, August 7, 2024

How my appreciation of My Hero Academia has grown

This month, Kohei Horikoshi will be finishing My Hero Academia. Ten years worth of weekly chapters and I think it will end up being 42 volumes. 

While there are works like One Piece that are over a hundred volumes, that’s still ten years and a lot of pages. And it’s clear that My Hero Academia is telling a single complete story.

I’ve read thirty-five of the volumes and only stopped because that’s how much the library had lol And my enjoyment and appreciation of My Hero Academia has only grown as it has gone on.

And, as I keep reading it, I kept adjusting my expectations and impressions of the series.

Spoilers

Spoilers

Spoilers

Spoilers

Spoilers 

Spoilers

Spoilers 

I had initially described My Hero Academia as school for superheroes. I ultimately feel that I was wrong. It is an inter-generational saga where some of the action takes at a school. I’d actually say it’s less about good versus evil and more people who want to help versus people who want to hurt.

And the concept of Superhero is central to the work. Not just the concept of super powers but the idea of using them to help people. At first, in a world where 80% has super powers, the government is actively involved in licensing heroes and super heroics is big business, it felt like Horikoshi was deconstructing Superheroes. However, after the setting was established, he began reconstructing the concept.
 
And the centerpiece to that reconstruction is Midoriya, the protagonist but still part of a sprawling ensemble. Basically, personality-wise, he is Superman. The Superman of My Adventures with Superman, not Zack Snyder’s Superman. (Although, to be honest, given the timeline, I wouldn’t be surprised if My Hero Academia influenced My Adventures with Superman) Midoriya is empathic and caring, even when in life and death battles.

In fact, the two students who get the second most focus, Bukago and Shoto, are different flavors of anti-hero. Mind you, they are both shown to be able to grow and be good people (Bukago hides his better side very well) But it is
Midoriya’s compassion that is a key component to his ability to make a difference. That and incredible powers.

And this is what ultimately sold me and got me hooked. Midoriya may have a silver age outlook but he isn’t in a silver age world. The villains are absolute nightmares whose actions have serious body counts and cause societal collapse. There are serious stakes in My Hero Academia.

I feel the Dark Hero arc has been the most striking for me so far. Midoriya has left the academy because he is so dangerous to be around. And, at his lowest point, when he is neglecting basic hygiene and nutrition, Midoriya is relentlessly trying to help people, fighting violent criminals and rescuing people. Even at his lowest, Midoroya still needs to save everyone but he needs his friends to remind him that he also needs save himself.

I don’t know My Hero Academia will end. (I’m mean, I’m pretty sure it will be a happy ending) Considering it’s become a multi-media franchise with spin-offs, this month isn’t the end of the setting. But I hope Horikoshi will end the central story well.

Wednesday, June 19, 2024

Chi’s Sweet escape from reality

You would think that I’d been meaning to read Chi’s Sweet Home because I am a life long cat lover. But no, I decided to pick up Chi’s Sweet Home because I saw so many students reading it, including students who I really didn’t expect to read anything at all.

Spoiler: I quickly realized that there isn’t much actual reading involved in Chi’s Sweet Home. And that’s the last mean thing I will say about it.

Chi’s Sweet Home is a slice-of-life manga about a kitten who gets adopted by a family after she gets lost. It is so soft and gentle that it makes Ai Yori Aoshi look like Berserk. (Or if video game analogies are more your thing, it makes Animal Crossing look like Dark Souls)

The last cat-centric manga I read was A Man and His Cat, the story of a widower who adopts an unwanted cat and how they ease each other’s loneliness. I haven’t finished the first volume of that because it’s hard to read when you’re crying that hard. It’s beautiful but has serious feels.

I was worried that Chi’s Sweet Home would also be emotionally rough. However, at least in the first volume, it wasn’t nearly so traumatic. Yes, Chi gets lost from her mother and still dreams of her. However, the stories are more focused on sweet life moments.

Amusingly, Chi’s Sweet Home is Seinen, the young adult men genre. (Not porn but the next step up from Shonen) Because it is published in a Seinen magazine. While it is as child friendly as Bluey. Which is just further proof that genre categories are garbage.

That said, part of its strength is that it can be quite frank about daily life. Chi’s struggles getting litter box trained (she is a very young kitten) and her stress visiting the vet are clearly conveyed. As a pet owner and a parent, Chi’s Sweet Home rings true.

But the reason to read Chi’s Sweet Home is how it celebrates the quiet joys and tiny victories. It is a refuge from the big, scary world. And it’s a series I know I won’t binge but I will keep going back to.

Thursday, May 9, 2024

My spoiler-free first reaction to My Hero Academia

I heard enough about the manga  My Hero Academia over the years that I finally decided to give it a go.

It’s basically school for superheroes. 

Yes, there’s a lot more going on than that and I’m pretty sure it will go beyond that. However, superhero school is the cornerstone and if you can’t get beyond that, it’s just not going to work.

(Is it weird that to me while the X-Men were technically always a school but it never felt like one until the 2000s because there was never a real student body until then?)

It is a Shonen manga and, oh boy, is it ever Shonen. It reads to me like mashup of Sports story and an action/adventure story.  Midoriya, the protagonist, is having a coming of age story as he slowly masters his Superman-like potential. It’s like the creator Horikoshi wrote a checklist of Shonen elements.

So, is it any good?

I have to admit that I was not impressed at first. It felt like a parody of a sports manga with being a superhero being a comedic standin for being a professional athlete. All Might, the Superman/ Captain America figure, in particular, seemed like a parody. The initial introduction of superhero economics seemed silly and the world building felt shallow.

But I kept trudging away, hoping to find the magic everyone said was there.

Then came the point when actual supervillains showed up. Not rivals at the school. Murderers and terrorists. Serious, dangerous plot elements.

Suddenly, My Hero Acamdeia had stakes.

The world stopped being one where superpowers were economic commodities and one where they were matters of life and death. Characters get horribly hurt and death seems like a real possibility. 

All Might stops being  a silly figure as we are shown how much he has risked and sacrificed. More than that, as opposed to an ideal word where super hero shenanigans just get to happen, we are shown that his example of morality may be all that keeps the world from sliding into a dystopia.

I went from wondering why I should care to Shogoth got real.

It took a bit but I eventually saw why folks get engaged by My Hero Acadenia and why the characters are interesting. How there is a deeper world beneath the shallow sports metaphor and that world is scary.

So I’ll keep reading. (I was on volume four when I started writing this and I’m on volume ten as I finish it up lol)

Monday, April 22, 2024

My unreasonable expectations of Drops of God

Earlier this year, I bought a digital manga bundle that included the complete Drops of God. Indeed, that was a big reason I bought it. I've long been interested in reading Drops of God, which takes wine tasting to soap opera extremes (but not Dragonball Z extremes)

I wrote about the series when I was at the halfway point. Now, I've finished it. Did it live up to the potential of the first half?

spoilers

spoilers

spoilers

spoilers

Oh so many spoilers

spoilers

spoilers

Nothing but spoilers

spoilers

Okay, I was ultimately disappointed by how Drops of God resolved itself and that was because it didn't resolve itself. I was aware that there was at least one follow-up series, Drops of God: Marriage. Knowing that, I found that many elements in the later part of Drops of God were actually setting up for that. A whole group of characters, the Watkins family, I now see were really being set up to be major players in the next series.

As a comparison, when I was younger, I read Dragonball and its transition to Dragonball Z. While it was clear at the end of Dragonball that Goku's adventures weren't done (because he is a loveable but psychotic manchild who lives for fighting) but all the conflicts were resolved. In Drops of God, barely anything is resolved.

Well, the Twelve Apostles, the wine identification test that determined which son would inherit  Yutaka Kanzaki’s vast wine collection, that gets settled. However, since a more extreme wine identification competition (the titular Drops of God) immediately starts, there's no sense of pause, let alone closure.

One element in particular I wanted to see addressed, if not resolved, is that Issei is actually Shizuku's half-brother, that the Twelve Apostles competition is actually a true family affair. However. while Shizuki does figure it out, no one ever brings it up and takes the matter to at least the next step of talking about it.

More than that, as the series progresses, it becomes clear that Yutaka Kanzaki was a terrible father and husband. Issei in particular was clearly damaged by his negligence. However, that seems to get glossed over since Yutaka Kanzaki was an absolute wine god so that makes it all right. That kind of rubs me the wrong way and I hope it gets addressed in Drops of God: Marriage.

With that said, the fact that the Twelve Apostles were an autobiography in wine form became even more apparent in the second half. That is an interesting and engaging form of storytelling. If the ‘ending’ fell short, the journey was fascinating.

The side stories also reflect the life experience that the wines are expressing. With the final wine being about death and loss, one of the major supporting characters develops pancreatic cancer. It is such a well written gut punch that it helped me get over the lack of closure for the overall series.

It can be argued that my expectations for Drops of God to tell a complete story aren't reasonable since the continuation was clearly intended. And the art and writing of the series is solid. Glad I read it. Good stuff.  Annoyed at having to hunt down another series. 

Wednesday, February 28, 2024

Is Drops of God THE wine manga?

 I’ve been meaning to read Drops of God for years and I’ve finally started doing that. Actually, I’m halfway through and taking a break.


Drops of God is a Seinen manga (which means it’s aimed at men between the ages of 18 and 40 basically the next step up from Shonen and is, in many ways pretty arbitrary) about wine. And, while the plot is about Shizuki Kanzaki and Issei Tomine in a wine identification contest, a _lot_ of time is spent discussing real wines and vineyards.

Drops of God is epicurean in a way that I don’t feel I’ve seen in a western work. As far as I know, no vineyard sponsored it and it isn’t in the style of a documentary. It is this blend of fiction and actual factual information.

And, for what it’s worth, red wine gives me headaches so a lot of what I’m reading about is purely theoretical for me. (Although I’m sure every member of the cast would tell me I just haven’t had the right red wine)

That said, it’s the fictional stuff that actually drives the story forward. 

While the story frames Shizuki as the hero and Tomine as the antagonist, they are really deuteragonists. More than that, at least in the first half, they seem to be in different genres.

Shizuki feels like a Shonen protagonist who has stumbled into a Sienen work. He is a plucky newcomer to wine but one with an almost supernatural palate. (Justified by his father putting him through an insane regiment as a child) And he some definite moments of being an awkward goof. 

More than that, a lot of his side adventures, involve him helping out other people. In general, there are a lot of altruistic elements to his part of the story.

On the other hand, Tomine feels a lot more like a Sienen protagonist. He is a much more brooding, troubled character. He’s the one who gets the racy sex scenes. His side adventures have more danger but it’s danger that he often brings on himself.

Shizuki’s flaws are those of innocence. Tomine’s flaws are from the loss of innocence. But Drops of God asks for us to be invested in both of them.

I do plan on reading the second half, particularly since I don’t think it’s guaranteed that Shizuki will win. And I’ll learn more about wine I’ll never drink.

Wednesday, November 8, 2023

Finding out how bizarre Jojo’s Bizarre Adventure is

 For years upon years, I have heard of Jojo’s Bizarre Adventure. It is an incredibly long running and ridiculously influential manga about the generations of the Jostar family and their relentless battles against evil.

Well, I’m finally reading some of it.


I’ve been reading the seventh arc, Steel Ball Run. I chose Steel Ball Run for three reasons. First, it was a continuity reset so a good jumping on point. Two, at least in the United States, it is regarded as one of the best arcs. And, three, it’s what the library had.


If Jojo’s Bizarre Adventure is known for one thing in particular, it’s for the concept of stands. Added in the third arc (so it took years to make it into the series), it’s basically the idea that you have an entity that you can manifest that has super powers. You can order it around but you’re still a squishy human being. So, it’s the basically Negative Man from the 60s Doom Patrol taken to nth level. 


And, at least by Steel Ball Run, stands were definitely getting bizarre. Have your fingernails spin and shoot off like bullets is a relatively mundane one. This isn’t Jojo’s Justice League. There’s a lot of both imagination and disturbed ideas in the stands.


Steel Ball Run is about a horse race across the United States 1890. Except that the race, which involved hundreds of riders, is actually the cover for a search for the parts of a mummified body that is very strongly implied to be Jesus Christ.


I can’t believe I typed that sentence and it wasn’t about a Call of Cthulhu campaign.


The Jojo of this generation is Johnny Jostar, a paraplegic jockey. After he got a hint of the weird mystic stuff that was going on, he joined the race hoping to find a way to walk again. And he is very much an anti-hero. I don’t mean an anti-hero like Wolverine or the Punisher. I mean like Willy Loman from the Death of a Salesman. 


I’m only a third of the way through the Steel Ball Run but I can see the appeal of the series. A high concept plot, profoundly weird powers and deeply flawed and struggling characters.


I do t know if I will read any other arcs of Jojo’s Bizarre Adventure (because there’s so much) but I want to see the end of the Steel Ball Run.

Thursday, October 19, 2023

Tumbling back into One Piece

Since the Netflix One Piece got me back in a One Piece of mind, I let myself get drawn back into reading the manga.

The thought of starting from the start again horrified me so I picked up where I left off. It’s been more than ten years but I was able to figure that out without much trouble. (It also helped that I can get volumes digitally from the library, saving both money AND space. Seriously, I had multiple shelves devoted to One Piece)

And so I have now read the Water Seven Arc.

Spoilers
 
Spoilers

Spoilers

Spoilers

Spoilers

Spoilers

I amazed at how easily I found myself back into Oda’s madcap world. I’ve wondered what the best single word to describe Oda as an artist and I think it might be enthusiasm. And that enthusiasm pulls you through the world in a way that makes you amazed at how much you actually ended up reading.

Back when I was regularly reading One Piece (and I honestly read only a tiny fraction of the series), I also read about the series. In a general way, I knew some of what was to come. And a lot of what I knew was to come happened in Water Seven lol

I knew Luffy and Usopp would have a major fight that resulted in Usopp leaving the group, only to come back in a mask. I knew that the Strawhats would declare war on the world government to save Robin. I knew that the Going Merry would sink and be replaced by the Thousand Sunny. I knew the Strawhats would get a shipwright who was a cyborg named Franky.

That all happened in Water Seven.

I will note that, in a series with lots of feels, the death of the Going Merry was the most powerful gut punch Oda has given me.

And I had low expectations for Franky, feeling naming him after Frankenstein was pretty low hanging fruit. When he turned out to be a cross between the Six Million Dollar Man, a fifties greaser and Popeye, I was won over. Truly, he is super.

One Piece is a beautiful, sprawling mess that I thought I was finished with. It was fun being wrong.