Tuesday, September 6, 2016

If John Hughes directed a RPG

If you were looking for a role playing game that let you relive movies like Sixteen Candles or Some Kind of Wonderful, Unrequited fits that bill. In fact, that's pretty much all you're going to do with it.

Unrequited is a short form role-playing game for two players. One player will play the Infatuated, who is in love with the Crush, an NPC. The other player plays the Friend, who supports the Infatuated but is secretly in love with the Infatuated. 

Yeah, you can see where this is going.

You play out three scenes, heightening the Infatuated's obsession with the Crush and depending the Friend's love for the infatuated. Throughout the scenes, you develop dice pools that will help determine who ends up with who at the end of the game.

One of the things that I don't like about how you earn those dice. You get them by performing very specific actions during the scene. While the rules state that the setting can be anywhere, the actions are really, really geared towards a John Hughes style 80s teen movie. Seriously, I can't see using this rule set with any other kind of setting.

What I do like is that the Friend can choose to give their dice pool to the Infatuated to help them win the love of the Crush, sacrificing their love for the desires of the Crush. It's pretty standard for the genre but it is the most dramatic choice in the game. Perhaps the only dramatic choice.

In short form games, particularly narratively driven games, I do think that it is important to have a strong framework. A lot of games, you go in knowing what kind of story they are trying to tell and the framework helps you tell that kind of story. In the case of Unrequited, I feel like the structure is so rigid that it's telling me how the story is to be told in addition to what the story will be. In fact, if we were given a very specific setting and three pregenerated characters for the three roles, I think that it would bother me less because the rigid structure would make more sense. 

Unrequited suffers from comparison to a number of games. For me, the most obvious one is Breaking the Ice. Two player, romance games aren't part of my RPG interest but the depth and many interesting choices in Breaking the Ice would make it my game of choice. 

Since Unrequited is part of the Indie Mixtape Megamix, I also can't help but compare it the game right before it on the play list, A Courteous Night, another romantic short form for two. And one that I feel allows for more interesting choices and more freedom, despite also having a very tight structure.

Interestingly enough, although there are other was not very much alike, since the scenes in Unrequited are all conversations, I find myself reminded of Until We Sink. That's a Nordic LARP that consists of nothing but conversations around the table. Making it a tabletop LARP, I guess. 

Unrequited isn't a game that I can see myself playing, even if I was in the mood for a romantic game. It's certainly not a game I can see playing twice.

Friday, September 2, 2016

The Wouldbegoods - good but not Nesbit's best

As part of my reading of public domain children's literature in general and A. E. Nesbit in particular, I just finished reading The Wouldbegoods, her second book about the Bastable siblings. 

The Bastables are one of the prototypes for kids who innocently get into trouble. Their hearts may be in the right place but they have serious issues with bad judgment and poor impulse control.

In the Wouldbegoods, they set out to become better people during a summer holiday in the countryside. A holiday that they were required to go on after wrecking their uncle's yard and taxidermy collection. Needless to say, chaos follows every good deed they tried to do and every game they try to play.

I pretty much have to compare it to the first book, the Story of the Treasure Seekers.  On the one hand, I found the second book a more enjoyable and fun read. And on the other hand, I found the first book to be deeper and more meaningful.

You see, the poor judgement of the Bastables makes you seriously wonder if there is something wrong with these kids. And, it becomes rapidly obvious in the first book that there is. Underneath their jolly play, they are clearly traumatized by the death of their mother and by their father losing everything when his partner embezzled the company into the ground. 

Their lives are much improved by the second book, which means that we are not reading about a group of kids who are clinging together in order to keep it together. Which is definitely more upbeat but not nearly as moving.

One thing that I have to give these books is that the kids don't get away with any of their accidental hijinks. There are definite consequences to their actions. One of the most striking scenes in the book is the younger daughter practically having a breakdown after discovering that a good deed overturned a barge and dump out a load of coal. The kids are well aware of how many scrapes they get into, even though they can't seem to learn from them. 

The book does get kind of formulaic. Each chapter, we read about how the Bastables have some kind of poorly thought idea and how it will inevitably blow up on them. It's not one of Nesbit's strongest works, particularly compared to the first book. 

Still, the Wouldbegoods is an interesting, if sometimes dated (and even racist) look at the beginnings of modern children's literature.

http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/794

Thursday, September 1, 2016

Skipping fantasy football

Last year, I tried out Fantasy Football for the first time. A bunch of my friends from back in the Midwest were forming a league and it was a way to have fun with them.

There ended up being two issues. One, I'd never played any fantasy sports games before and only had a general idea of how it worked. Two, I have a burning apathy for football. I don't think there is a professional sport I'm less interested in.

Initially, I had fun with the idea of gaming through statistics and trash talking with my buddies. But, as the season ground on, trying to keep up with my moves just got to be drudgery. Who was playing, who was injured, how well someone was doing and what position they played.

Having to pay attention to football didn't spark some hidden and unrealized love for the game. Instead, it made me start to feel an actual dislike for the game.

So this year, I am bowing out. I think it was important to give fantasy football the chance. It would not be fair or reasonable to reject it untried. However, now that I have tried it and found that I didn't have any fun, I'm OK not playing.

Monday, August 29, 2016

Couple little PnP projects

I have found myself working on a couple of little Print and Play projects without even meaning to.

Some months ago, I took note of Mint Works when it was part of a Print and Play contest with the specific requirement that the game had to fit into a mint tin.

Mint Works stood out to me because it was a worker placement game, consisting of less than twenty cards and some tokens. I've seen a lot of micro games but this was the first worker placement micro game I'd seen.

It's now on Kickstarter so I decided to make a copy from the files from the contest in order to check it out. Got to check out the twin questions of fun and replayability.

I've also begun work on the B&W PnP version of Herbaceous, a game about drafting cards and collecting sets. The theme appeals to us and I'm going to try and color the cards by hand. Which might be silly  and might mean we might not try until after that Kickstarter is over but it will be fun.

Thursday, August 25, 2016

Rose colored glasses and getting into games

I have been spending a lot of time going down memory lane, both remembering some of my early game experiences and some of the games that helped get me into gaming. However, there are some elements of those formative times that I had really forgotten about until I started looking at them more closely.

I had remembered how they were so many amazing games out there that I'd never heard of. Effectively, I was years behind in the cult of the new. So there were many games that were new to me that had years of people vetting them and figuring out what games were good.

So, my rose colored memories make it seem like I had just entered a candy store of gaming. However, what I realized I was overlooking was how limited my access to that candy store was.

By the time we moved out of Chicago, there was a gaming store fifteen minutes from where we lived and there's one about ten minutes away from us here in Tucson. When I first started, I'd have to drive out to the suburbs (Hi, Games Plus!)

For that matter, the online retail market wasn't as rich, although that was still the main way I got most of my games. And the idea of finding a game like Catan or Carcassonne in a store like Target was silly.

By the time we left Chicago, a lot of my friends had good-sized game collection. Pretty much anyone I've gamed with since getting to Arizona has had a collection. 

So, back when I first was looking at designer games, if I wanted to try something, I had to buy it. This probably helped me buy too many games and be the game closet for a bunch of my friends.

The internet did give me two really amazing resources. Boardgame Geek was an amazing site to research games. Breitspielwelt, an online German board game site, was how I did get try out games.

Yes, it was an amazing experience to discover designer board games. But I have to remember that it actually took some effort to get into them.

Wednesday, August 24, 2016

42

I turned 42 today.

To be honest, I'm kind of past the point where I really think about the number. The last time I thought about it was when I turned thirty and I dreamed I was surrounded by teenagers chanting I wasn't a hepcat anymore.

To be fair, thirty was kind of 'What am I doing with my life?' In comparison, when I turned forty, I was married, had moved across the country and had an infant son. That was more of 'Wow! Look at what I've done with my life!'

But as someone who read his copies of Douglas Adams until they were literally in pieces as a teenager, I have to acknowledge forty-two.

Even folks who don't know Douglas Adams from Evelyn Waugh know that forty-two is the answer to the ultimate question of life, the universe and everything.

I swear that in the annotated scripts to the radio plays, Adams stated that the whole point was that it didn't mean anything (although I bet it has come to mean something to a lot of people) 

But I am going to take this from it. Yeah, the number isn't important. What matters is what I've done with those years. And, while there have been some bumps and twists along the way, it just keeps getting better.

Tuesday, August 23, 2016

The Life and Adventures of Santa Claus: Baum tackles the big red guy

The Life and Adventures of Santa Claus is just what it says on the tin, an origin story for Santa Claus. After the Wizard of Oz, it might be the most influential book that L. Frank Baum wrote.

I don't think that someone could write a book like the Life and Adventures of Santa Claus today. Baum wrote it in a fairy tale, folk story manner, very much honoring the idea that he was writing about children's beliefs. I think it would be hard for someone to approach the same material today without deconstructing it. And the mythology of Santa Claus is now so codified that it is practically set in stone. Baum wrote about Santa Claus before so much was defined, even though the book helped create some of those ideas, like Santa having magical assistants.

Only a few decades later, Seabury Quinn wrote Roads, an origin of Santa Claus as well as a deconstruction of Santa Claus with Santa as a Viking who served under both King Herod and Ponticus Pilate. It's an audacious book on the sheer idea alone but no one is going to accuse to of trying to create a Santa Claus that's true to the folklore.  

The Life and Adventures of Santa Claus starts with being found as orphan baby by Fairies, who bring him up. After he grows up and goes out into the world, Claus learns of the suffering and sorrows of the world. Since children are the most innocent, he decides to help them by creating toys. Both as a concept and a physical object. As the scope of his toy work grows, the varies benevolent magical races help out. When Santa Claus grows old and dying, the magical races decide to grant him immortality through the power of a one-use magical item, so he can help out children for all time.

Oh, and basically behind Santa Claus's back, there is a major war between the nice enchanted races and the nasty ones who want to end his toy making, children helping ways.

I've actually read this book a number of times over the years. It's a pretty good read. While you know from the start how it's going to end (well, maybe the not immorality bit but Santa becoming Santa), it has some odd twists like that war.

And, as much as Baum's work has any kind of coherent cosmology, The Life and Adventures of Santa Claus defines it. It describes the benevolent races of fairies and ryls and knooks, as well as mentioning the original version of the land of Mo and the nomes. Baum never let continuity get in the way of a good story but this book gives us the clearest framework of his fantasy world.

The Life and Adventures of Santa Claus is a good book for understanding the work of Baum but it's also a very good children's book.