Friday, January 25, 2019

My ongoing adventures with micro games - Slicer

Slicer is 1) a free PnP game 2) a solitaire 3) just nine cards with some dice and tokens 4) an incredibly abstract interpretation of computer hacking. Yup, that about covers it.

In the spirit of William Gibson devotees everywhere, you are a hacker who is hacking their way through a series of servers in order to reach and open up a corporate database. So, each card represents a server and you roll dice in order to successfully hack it. (Am I even using that verb right?)

Slicer has different modes of play. Each mode has you lay out the cards in a different pattern and easy mode makes it easier to successfully hack servers. In fact, you might even win on your first turn on easy mode since the database is shuffled in. On the other hand, the layers of cards you need to go through on hard might require loaded dice.

To add to the fun, you have to complete the game in six turns and messing up a roll can cost you two turns. You do get two to three tokens that let you bend the rules a bit.

Proverbially cards on the table. Slicer is not a good game. It really boils down to flip a card and roll three dice and hope you roll high. The dice and card manipulation that your help tokens give you isn’t enough to really give you choices or control. When I’m complaining about the lack of control in a nine-card, six-round game, it’s pretty bad.

That said, there are some things I like about Slicer. It’s a super easy build. I like the variable set-ups. And it works well as a parent break game, taking up little space, time or brain power.

What Slicer really reminds me of is Muses, another nine-card and some dice game. Muses, which I’ve bashed, is better though, because it allows more dice manipulation. I ended up playing Muses than I ever expected because it works so well as a parent break and I suspect that I’ll do the same with Slicer.

I do think Slicer missed a trick by not giving any of the cards special powers. For instance, being allowed to flip a card after successfully hacking a midrange server would add decisions to the game.

I wouldn’t recommend Slicer for anyone to make. Still, I don’t regret making it and it will see some play from me.

Thursday, January 24, 2019

The guilty pleasure of Prince of Tennis

It has been said that the only genre of sports movies is the scrappy underdogs overcoming the odds. I really want to know who said that but it really seems to be true from The Bad News Bears to Sea Biscuit to The Mighty Ducks to Rocky (well, he did go the distance) to Major Leagues to etc.

To be fair, it’s one of the easiest ways of creating drama and tension. I mean, watching a movie about Michael Jordon being awesome would be fun but we wouldn’t be wondering how it would end.

But that’s a lot of why I really liked the manga Prince of Tennis enough to read a couple dozen volumes of it back when it was first getting published in the U.S. Because it completely subverts that theme.

Ryoma and all of the other players at Seigaku aren’t introduced as newbies to tennis who turn out to be prodigies or who have to learn that hard work and practice can make champions out of them. No, these middle schoolers start out as physical gods who laugh at the laws of physics and just get more ridiculous from there.

In fact, Ryoma is kind of an immature brat :D Although he is a twelve-year-old who has gone Batman levels of training in tennis by his crazy monk dad so he kind of has an excuse for being both arrogant and immature. He’s young and not a prodigy but someone who worked hard to be insanely good.

But I’m getting off track. Prince of Tennis entertained me so much because it wasn’t about plucky underdogs. It’s about the Dragon Ball Z of tennis matches. It’s not about the heroes overcoming the odds. It’s about the heroes overcoming the laws of physics, common sense and reality.

Maybe if I’d seen more subversions of the underdog theme, I wouldn’t have been so charmed by Prince of Tennis. Then again, it jumps into its madness feet first and no apologies. Maybe it’d have been fun no matter what.

But Ryoma and his friends are no Bad News Bears. They’re Greek gods with tennis rackets.

Wednesday, January 23, 2019

What will we pay for free?

One of the selling points of Print and Play is that it’s a way to get ‘free’ games. Which is, of course, patently untrue. You always have material costs, even if the download is free.

That said, as long as you have a reliable printer, some games are virtually free and there are other ways to moderate the cost. Having a tool box of assorted dice, tokens, dry erase markers and pawns is an investment that goes a long ways. 

Having said that (and there’s a lot to say about budget PnP), you also have to ask yourself what you’re willing to settle for for ‘free’. To quote my dad, if you wouldn’t pay a dime for it, why are you bothering getting it for free?

Now, I freely admit that I personally give more leeway for PnP games than I would for a published game that I would have to pay quite a bit more for. Particularly if it is not from an established publisher but from a hobby designer. (If I have paid for the files, my standards go up) But there is a definite line.

Shortly after I first discovered Boardgame Geek, I tried out Malta Convoy. All it takes to make it is printing out a page and adding dice. However, it’s a game where you barely have any choices. It’s mostly rolling the dice and recording what they tell you to record.

I’d still probably pull out Malta Convoy and play it out of nostalgia value but there are literally dozens of games I’d recommend over it that are also print and add dice. Being free just isn’t enough. Even a free PnP game has to have some value.

There’s definitely a tipping point for me. What got me thinking about the value of ‘free’ games was Outlaw. Outlaw is basically a poor cousin to Pikomino, tossing dice in order to claim spots to earn points. It’s another game that doesn’t require any more construction than print the board and add dice and tokens.

Outlaw is, honestly, a so-so game. It’s too easy to have a null round or even accidentally knock one of your own tokens off the board. The game can become a grind. It doesn’t have the legs to be a game I’d want to play a lot of.

But, I have seen dice games that publishers were asking money for that were worse. In fact, I’d say that Outlaw is actually pretty middle of the road for light dice games, which is a genre I think it pretty fun and easy to get folks into.

So Outlaw is a game that I made a laminated board for and it’s a game I’ve recommended to people. It’s not brilliant but it is a good return for ‘free’. It passed the threshold.

All that said, what I’ll settle in the name of ‘free’ hasn’t been as big a deal recently. Over the last few years, I really think a lot of solid PnP games have come out. PnP contests and prototypes with Kickstarter in mind probably has a lot to do with that. I will happily listen to any argument to the contrary but I think you have to settle for ‘free’ a lot less than when I started.

Monday, January 21, 2019

The two minutes I thought Twilight Creations was out of business

When doing some research about Twilight Creation’s Dante’s Inferno, I discovered that their website no longer existed.

Which made me rather sad and slightly surprised. Other than Easter Island (which is probably one of their more obscure games), I really don’t like any of their games and will actively avoid most of them. However, I do kind of like the company.

Don’t get me wrong. Their component quality can be questionable (Indeed, the muddy color palette of Zombiegeddon made it unplayable). Their rulebooks can be horrible. And their mechanics often seem like they need more serious playtesting.

But Twilight Creations has always struck me as a scrappy company that wasn’t afraid of experimenting and taking risks. They were making zombie games with miniatures before that was cool. Heck, they paved the way to make it cool. Sure, I hate Zombies! but I’m not going to knock the many folks who do like it and its family of games. (I will judge Munchkin fans though)

So, Twilight Creations going away made me kind of sad. I googled to double check. Facebook? They are still in business, have a Kickstarter campaign coming up and sorry about their website having issues?

Okay, that’s good :)

Thursday, January 17, 2019

Derailing HellRail

HellRail: Third Perdition was a game that I really wanted to like. Yeah, when I start off like that, you know that I didn’t like it.

The theme, as if you couldn’t guess, was running trains in Hell. You are trying to deliver damned souls to the different circles of Hell. Yes, it has a very Dante feel. The art is more a fire and brimstone, renaissance Hell than a metal or cutesie one. According to the rules, the winner gets to put off burning in the pits for one more day. So feel good.

Okay, who doesn’t love train games? And trains in Hell? Doesn’t that sound cool in a black nail polish kind of way? But what was really cool is that, except for tiny wooden trains, the entire game is made up of square cards that do everything. The cards can be used as tracks for the map, cargo, points and fuel. 

I first came across it in 2006. I’d already discovered multi-use cards through San Juan but HellRail was still one of my earlier experiences with the idea and I thought it was super cool. And it was a full train game (pick up and deliver, track development, resource management) that was condensed down to a deck of square cards. That was super cool. 

So where did it all go wrong?

First of all, since you use the cards for EVERYTHING, you burn through the deck fast. The game feels like it should be at least as twice as long. The tracks and deliveries are just starting to get going and the game ends.

I’d actually considered buying a second copy and combining the decks. And I’m glad I didn’t because that wouldn’t have solved the other problem.

HellRail is really random. Too random. In games like San Juan or Race for the Galaxy, specific cards only matter for one purpose (adding them to your tablea) Otherwise, be it goods or money, cards are equal. Every use of a card in HellRails depends on the specific card you’re playing. Which makes it too easy to derail any planning you’re doing and one bad enough turn can actually completely kill your chances of winning the game.

And in a train game, that level of random just isn’t fun. I’m not against random but HellRail took it to a frustrating place, 

Years later, I tried HellRail again and honestly found it even worse. Time has not been kind of HellRail. It has not aged well. I have a feeling that it was more of a standout game almost twenty years ago but so many better light pick-up-and-deliver games have been created since then. Some games are timeless (Hi Acquire!) but HellRail felt dated and not in a retro, fun way.

A light and flexible pick-up-and-deliver game is really something to be applauded. It’s a very satisfying genre for me and an accessible one that can fit into under an hour is something I really look for. But HellRail fell apart, particularly when there are a lot of better options out there.

HellRail had a lot of mechanical ideas that really appealed to me but, I got to admit, what it might have done is proven how some of them don’t work.



Tuesday, January 15, 2019

Glancing at Knizia’s approach to MtG

I’m a bit of an oddball because I prefer Scarab Lords/Minotaur Lords to Blue Moon/Blue Moon Legends. Both families are generally considered to be Reiner Knizia’s response to collectible card games like Magic so it’s kind of only natural to compare them.

My preference has pretty much nothing to do with the actual games itself. No one on my old gaming circles was interested in Blue Moon but there were one or two guys who really dug the Lords so I got to play it a lot more.

Truth to tell, if I had a chance to play more Blue Moon, I might change my mind. And, truth to tell, the games approach similar ideas in different ways, so comparing them might not make that much sense.

Both games involve old school deck building. You know, where you build the deck before you start playing :P And both have a core mechanic of using cards to build up numbers.

However, the Lords games are more traditional game in a box. You have core decks that you can tweak a little through out a multi-round game. The Blue Moon family has far more decks, which serve as a pool of cards to build, making it more like a traditional deck builder :D

In my very limited experience, I think that the Lords games have more intricate actual ‘in the game’ play. Blue Moon seems to have more simple game play but much more complex deck building and meta game. While I bought and have kept most of the original decks, I haven’t looked through them so I’m sure there’s a lot of complexity I haven’t seen.

I’m torn between which game I’d like to explore more. I think that the Lords Games are more manageable and I already know them better. However, I think that really exploring the Blue Moon family might richer. The 






Monday, January 14, 2019

Milestones in my PnP life

There have been times when I feel like 2018 was when I started making PnP games but that’s balderdash. I’ve dabbled with print and play for many years. 

However, going through my notes, I can see how, since moving to Tucson, my interest in PnP really picked up. Yes, 2018 was something of a watershed year but I can see how that interest snowballed and what games and publishers were definite milestones.

Tiny Epic Defenders was a major one. Making the demo version during the Kickstarter was a big step for me as a crafter. Amusingly, it also convinced me to not back the game :D

The next major step for me was Button Shy games. Their pocket line of games gave me a wide variety of micro games to explore. They are easy enough to craft and enough of them are genuinely good enough to make them worth making.

Seriously, Button Shy opened a lot of doors for me, both in games to explore and ways of looking at both micro games and print and play games.

The last major milestone that really shook up my ideas and views was the 2017 GenCan’t Roll and Write Contest. I binged on Roll and Writes like I never had before and the best of them made me really reassess Roll and Writes as a genre. And the GenCan’t contest was also when my interest in solitaire gaming went beyond a mild interest and really snowballed.

Make no mistake. 2018 was a big year. I got a lot more serious and, more importantly, a lot more organized about print and play. It’s been a huge year for Print and Play for me but it didn’t come out of nowhere.